
Taking residents to court is the only punitive action City of Rockingham staff have to encourage people to keep their properties tidy after the council rejected giving them the power to issue on-the-spot fines.
The change was part of a proposed new health local law presented at the October 27 council meeting.
It included prohibiting refuse, rubbish or disused material which, in the opinion of city staff, created an “untidy appearance”, and “unsightly overgrowth of vegetation”.
The current law does not allow the city to give out infringement notices or modified penalties, meaning ongoing non-compliance can be addressed only through prosecution.
However, the maximum penalty under health local laws is $1000 and a council report said prosecutions were generally not in the city’s interest to pursue.
But the new rules, including on-the-spot fines, were rejected after the council vote was deadlocked 6-6. Deputy mayor Robert Schmidt had tried to have the item deferred to a later meeting but mayor Lorna Buchan said it came too late.
This is the second time the proposed law was rejected. A previous version was knocked back in June. Two workshops have since been held to try and iron out issues raised.
Cr David Rudman said he knew options to keep the city clean had to be explored but the policy was all-encompassing.
“It’s not just the maintenance of dwelling houses or a crackdown on residents with unsightly verges,” he said.
“There are approximately 87 sections and 400-plus subsections in this document.
“In my view, this is a legal minefield and we’re expected to vote on something that is as clear as mud.”

Cr Peter Hudson said the policy was “government overreach” and would remove “judicial discretion” if fines should be handed out.
“City staff ... are not appointed judges but they may, under this local law, have the authority to issue on-the-spot infringements,” he said.
“Residents can move to make appeals and lodge their own findings through the court system, but this is a fundamental shift here of the city as the enforcing authority ... and then forcing the resident to then defend themselves.
“A person should be considered innocent until they can be found to be in breach of the local law.”
Cr Mark Jones said under the previous rules, the only option the council had was to go to court, which was a “costly and time-consuming process”.
“I’m fairly comfortable with the changes to the health local law to make it easier for compliance and for people to clean up where necessary, rather than going to court in each instance,” he said.
He said he felt for residents who were having to live next door to messy properties.
Cr Dawn Jecks said the council had been shown the sorts of problems staff were dealing with.
“Some really graphic photos of people’s whole backyard covered in dog faeces. I’m talking the whole backyard, all up the side, rubbish everywhere,” she said.
“And at the moment, if the people don’t want to clean it up, we can’t really make them.
“We can give them warnings, all the rest of it, and the only way we can make them is just to say ‘look, we’ll take you to court’. And if we do take them to court, that costs lots of money.”

Cr Kelly Middlecoat said the city had “unlimited” resources and funds and it was “highly unfair” to take someone straight to court.
“I’ve had Baldivis residents contact me about a property whereby there were approximately four vehicles out front of the house,” she said.
“There were numerous gas bottles. There were numerous lithium batteries. With any spark in summer, that could blow up.
“Recently there were police out there, rangers out there, trying to clean up that property, and I would just prefer that the city take less extreme steps to try mitigate this issue, rather than trying to have a David and Goliath battle in court.”
Cr Leigh Liley also had concerns about the scope of the policy. She and Cr Mike Crichton said it should be deferred for a year to “get this right”.
“I take my hat off to a few people up in South Lake who live next door to rubbish tips,” Cr Liley said. “When I say rubbish tips, I’m talking about you could not see their backyard.”
Director planning and development Peter Ricci told the meeting fines would range from $200 to $1000, depending on the level of the offence, but they were usually the last option.
“Normally we get voluntary compliance through liaising with our customers,” Mr Ricci said.
“That is always our default position to get an outcome without having to go any further. Often the threat of an infringement will be enough to bring about compliance.”
He said about 2 per cent of cases — “and we do thousands each year” — ended in an infringement.
A council report said there was an expectation that the city take effective action to resolve complaints.
A video on social media last month showed piles of rubbish near the South Baldivis Community Centre.
Get the latest news from thewest.com.au in your inbox.
Sign up for our emails
