Australia and Türkiye, the co-presidents of the COP 31 climate summit, were slammed for the failure of almost 200 countries and international organisations to reach an agreement overnight on global warming.
The collapse of negotiations in the Turkish resort town of Antalya was a huge blow to Energy and Climate Change Minister Chris Bowen, who wanted to place Australia and himself at the centre of global climate diplomacy by negotiating a “cover decision” that could be know as the Antalya Pact.
Instead of emerging as a hero, he was blamed by a top British climate group for failing to close the gap between Arab oil producers and European nations who wanted tougher wording blaming oil and gas for global warming.
“It was definitely a failure of leadership,” the executive director of Climate Action UK, Catherine Pettengell, told Britain’s Sky News.
“There was far too much focus put on this cover decision and there was some real work that needed to either from Türkiye or Australia.”
Asked to clarify if she blamed the two co-presidents, she said: “Yes, both them, they were very much focused on their pet projects.”
Mr Bowen supported “electrification” or the world’s economy in cars, kitchen appliances and many other essential parts of modern place would be powered by electricity drawn from solar and wind farms.
Fearing that phasing out oil and gas power would come at a huge economic cost, other countries pushed for greater emphasis on a technology known as carbon capture and storage, which separates carbon dioxide emitted from energy plants before it enters the atmosphere.
Mr Bowen said it was not possible to bring both sides together because their “red lines (were) more irreconcilable”.

“There is nothing to do, we did all that we could,” he said.
The New York Times reported the negotiations were poorly organised, delegates could not work out what was going on and there was a lack of public communication.
“It’s not effective and it can’t build consensus,” Botswana negotiator Xolisa Joseph Ngwadla said, according to the outlet.
“The process is basically mismanaged.”

The summits are often criticised for providing a forum for poorer countries to demand subsidies from richer countries for cutting greenhouse gas emissions. As the world faces trade disruptions, major wars and surging inflation, big energy producers pushed back against demands that they share much of the cost of climate policies.
The Trump Administration, which placed securing access to reliable energy sources over fighting climate change, said: “The United States is focused on common sense, not climate nonsense. The Trump Administration will continue to work with our allies around the world to unleash affordable, reliable, secure energy sources.”
Former US vice president Al Gore, whose film An Inconvenient Truth helped drive the global climate movement, said it was “outrageous that a handful of petrostates have veto power over any mention of fossil fuels”. Activist Greta Thunberg, who attended the event, said before negotiations failed that the outcome could mean life or death for ”countless people”.
One of the main difference’s between Mr Bowen’s Labor government and the Coalition opposition is a 2050 target to eliminate emissions, on a net basis, of greenhouse gases.
Get the latest news from thewest.com.au in your inbox.
Sign up for our emails
